Looking at Appalachia

Looking at Appalachia | Sarah Hoskins - Part One

When you think of Lexington, Kentucky, you may not think of it being synonymous with Appalachia. But Lexington, just on the borderline of what the Appalachian Regional Commission defines as Appalachia, is by extension, Appalachian, heavily influenced by the people and culture of Appalachia proper (which also includes northern Alabama and northeastern Mississippi). When Sarah Hoskins first contacted me about participating in this series, it was clear to me her work was a good fit. I think you'll agree.

Her work in and around the black hamlets of Lexington is striking. Her approach to making these pictures has always been about relationships. Like most places in Appalachia, photographers, documentarians, and the like come to get something and they leave. Hoskins didn't come to just "get." For more than a dozen years, she's returned to these communities, these sacred places, to her friends and now extended family. It may be stating the obvious, but she knows this work couldn't be done without the people. Her work honors them.

Back Home to The Homeplace

In the fall of 2000 I stood in the middle of Frogtown Lane map in hand, I didn’t know a soul. On June 11, 2012 I lay strapped down in an emergency room in Somerset, Kentucky a hundred miles away from that lane.

I had left the African American hamlets of the Inner Bluegrass Region that morning, where I had been photographing for the past week as well as the past twelve years. My daughter and I had been on our way to Tuskegee University, where I was to give a lecture on my photography project that I call "The Homeplace." The residents of the hamlets arrived like the cavalry in Somerset within hours of the car accident, dropping everything to rescue my daughter and myself as well as all of our belongings including my cameras and film from the wreckage that was our car. The sky passes in blurs, fleeting and fast moments.  It began as I stood looking through a machine of glass and mirrors trying in an instant to capture all that was. I now feel the blur of lives that have left and I have lost. I am left with those static moments.  Wishing those moments would move and bring me back to all that was.

I am strapped down and can’t move. I know I have something running through my veins, as the pain is less. The florescent lights overhead are all that I can see. They blur as I am wheeled quickly through the halls. I am the patient that they make way for.  The captain of the medivac is still pushing me.  Numbers are called out, stats of heart rate and blood pressure. What is my name? What is my birthday? Do I remember what happened? I feel the tears run down my cheeks. I don’t. I know my daughter is alive and safe. I know that the medivac team rescued me from the small, ill equipped, and scary hospital that I was in. I have always been afraid of helicopters, today in my morphine haze I have never been so grateful to have been in one.

I am being wheeled through the in the emergency room of UK hospital in Lexington, Kentucky.  I am brought into yet another emergency room. I can still only look up. I see the eyes that are Derek’s, the same eyes his daddy had. He strokes my hair that is matted and covered in dried blood. His warm coal colored hand holds my cold pasty white one. The nurse says, “Only relatives are allowed in here. How are you two related?” I hear the smile in Derek’s voice, “It’s a long story."

In the decade after the Civil War African American settlements sprang up around the horse farms in Kentucky’s six-county Inner Bluegrass Region. These villages or hamlets, as they have come to be known were originally inhabited by freed slaves who were needed to work on the area farms. Today, many of the residents are descendents of the freed men and women who founded them. In some cases as many as six generations of a family have lived in succession on a “homeplace” in these communities. Some of these hamlets are prospering while the existence of others is tenuous. With each visit I make, I am continually told of people and places where “you need to go.”

The Homeplace is comfort. The place you can go back to no matter how many years have passed. It will always hold something familiar something safe.

My project is a tribute to the residents of these hamlets, a salute to the elders who learned of slavery at their grandparent’s knees and endured the Jim Crow south. Who lived ‘separate but equal’ and saw the decades of milestones and their impacts, including desegregation, social segregation, and ultimately the election of Barack Obama. The residents did much more than endure and survive negative circumstances; they rose above them and thrived.

Over the years, like so many other documentary photographers, I apply for grants to help me fund my work. I would love to be rewarded with funding; it would certainly help. But rewards come in different forms, as was the case when I first read this letter written over eight years ago by one of the residents:

"Her presence in our communities over the past four years has renewed a pride in the old hamlets. She is well-known and received by the older members of the communities who are often very skeptical when visitors “show up” but yet have been revitalized because someone is taking the time to show sincere interest and concern for them. I only wish I could fully express the importance of her work and what it means to all of us. From Maddoxtown to Jimtown, from New Zion to New Vine, from Utteringtown to Peytontown, from Bracktown to Cadentown (to name a few) she has made good friends who eagerly anticipate her arrival each time she ventures from Chicago, Illinois. As a result she has compiled a list of names—friends given to her by local residents, that is quite extensive and she manages to keep in contact with many of us by phone. She is so highly favored because she did not come to take away from us like so many do, but unknowingly she has restored a sense of pride once again in our African-American heritage."

I feel Derek squeeze my hand, I breath shallow and painful breaths, but I breathe.  I realize that I am not done yet, that I am back home to The Homeplace and I am rewarded yet again.

Sarah Hoskins December 7, 2012

 

Sarah Hoskins is a documentary photographer, educator, and lecturer currently splitting her time between Chicago, Illinois and Lexington, Kentucky. Her photographs have been included in over 100 exhibitions and are in the permanent collections of The Smithsonian Institution, The Library of Congress, the Museum of Fine Arts Houston, and many others. Her work has been featured on NPR, in American Photography, American Legacy Magazine, Foto8, F8, Photo District News, South X Southeast, The Digital Journalist, and many others. She received her BA from Columbia College Chicago.

All photographs © Sarah Hoskins. 1. Creek baptism, 2012. 2. The Sisters after meeting, 2011. 3. Sunday morn, 2001. 4. Collection, 2004. 5. Chopping tobacco, 2005. 6. Hog in tub, 2002. 7. Pot pies, 2012. 8. Lodge meeting, 2005. 9. Satellite dish and slave cabin, 2010. 10. Walker family reunion, 2011. 11. Basketball, 2005. 12. The Benevolent Sisters, their 99th year, 2004. 13. Housing tobacco, 2005. 14. Rev. Raglin, Zion Hill Days, 2009. 15. Show me the way, 2011.

Review: New Deal Photographs of West Virginia, 1934-1943

Hardcover| 8 x 9.5 inches | 240 pages | 150 black and white photographs West Virginia University Press, 2012 | $29.99

Between 1934 and 1943, ten photographers: Elmer "Ted" Johnson, Walker Evans, Ben Shahn, Arthur Rothstein, Carl Mydans, Edwin Locke, Marion Post Wolcott, John Vachon, John Collier, Jr., and Arthur Siegel, visited West Virginia as part of Roy Stryker's Farm Security Administration (FSA) photographic unit. The FSA's primary attention during this time was on the northern and southern coalfields, the three subsistence homestead communities (Arthurdale, Eleanor, and Tygart Valley), and two wartime assignments in Nicholas and Mason counties.

What Rivard offers in this beautifully presented book, is a collection of images by photographers whose work I know well of West Virginia at a time I never knew. I'm fascinated with how others see my home state. None of these photographers are from West Virginia, yet they managed to capture its essence, its livelihood. Perhaps one of the things I appreciate most about these pictures is that they were made at a time when photographs weren't nearly as a prevalent as they are today (Instagram, Facebook and the like). Unlike the War on Poverty images of Appalachia, these pictures were made with a different intent. I sense a true collective effort to document the people and stories of West Virginia when I look at these photographs and think about the photographers who made them. Rivard notes that, "The photographs in this book offer professional fine art photographs in support of these memories, snapshots, and stories."

She continues:

"It is beyond the scope of this book to explore why, especially in the past fifty years, the state became a poster child for a culture of poverty. Unfortunately, the media have focused on poverty and exaggerated backwoods-type images as representative of West Virginia. These images have left terrible scars on a number of people who have grown up in the state. They also continue to bring harm through the perceptions that some outsiders have formed of the state and its citizens."

Rivard does a more than fair job of including images from a variety of the photographers as well as the regions covered. As a Mingo County native, I was somewhat disappointed to not see any photographs of Williamson or outlying areas included in the Southern Coalfields section, given Mingo's rich coal heritage and importance in the labor movement. But I admit my bias and am including an image (not in the book) by Ben Shahn made in Williamson in 1935. Logan and McDowell counties are well represented in pictures by Ben Shahn and Marion Post Wolcott.

New Deal Photographs of West Virginia is a brilliant book, extremely well edited and designed. The photographic reproductions are sharp and well printed and with every image, the Library of Congress negative file number is included, which makes finding them online incredibly easy. I can only hope for a second volume.

Betty Rivard is an award-winning fine art landscape photographer. She has researched and coordinated three exhibits of FSA photographs of West Virginia and contributed to articles about the FSA Project to Wonderful West Virginia, Goldenseal, and West Virginia South magazines. She is a Social Worker Emeritus and traveled to every county in West Virginia during her 25-year career as a social worker and planner with the state. Rivard's photography portfolio can be seen here.

Here are a few of my favorites from New Deal Photographs of West Virginia:

1. Wives of coal miners talking over the fence. Capels, West Virginia. Marion Post Wolcott. September 1938. LC-USF34-050260-E. 2. Miner (Russian). Capels, West Virginia. Marion Post Wolcott. September 1938. LC-USF33-030077-M1. 3. Men in Sunday clothes with miners' clubhouse in the background. Omar, West Virginia. Ben Shahn. October 1935. LC-USF33-006200-M1. 4. Coming home from school. Mining town. Osage, Scotts Run, West Virginia. Marion Post Wolcott. September 1938. LC-USF34-050352-E.

Very special thanks to Elaine McMillion, director of Hollow: An Interactive Documentary, for arranging a review copy of New Deal Photographs of West Virginia.

Looking at Appalachia | Rob Amberg - Part Two

In Rob Amberg's essay Looking for Place, he writes about place, stereotypes, the dynamics of mountain culture, and the collective truth sought through documenting Appalachia. His genuineness and candor are as evident in his writing and photographs as they are in person. It's one thing to hold a photographer's book, to study the photographs and process what the photographer has written. It's another thing altogether to spend hours with a photographer while realizing that the authenticity of the work and the person are inseparable. Rob Amberg is the real deal. His pictures say it, but so does he.

The first work I saw of Amberg's was his Sodom Laurel Album (2002) book, which straightaway became my favorite Appalachian photobook and the book I've pointed people to when asked about the kind of book I'd like to do someday. I've spent hours with this book, studying the photographs, paying attention to the sequencing of the pictures, the layout, the text. It isn't just a visual story of Appalachian people and place, it's inseparably bound by wonderfully written vignettes into the lives of those, including Amberg, who grace these pages. Amberg offers us publicly the type of honesty and vulnerability one would expect in a private journal:

"Junior and I got into a heated argument once. It started over a card game, but was more complicated than that. It involved some things I had said I would do that I didn't follow through on. He had trusted me, counted me as someone who treated him differently, and I had dismissed him, just like everyone else."

Sodom Laurel Album is the kind of photobook I can't pass by and not buy (think Mel Gibson's compulsion to buy The Catcher in the Rye in Conspiracy Theory). I've probably given away a half-dozen copies to friends over the years and I still have two on my bookshelf. I've only recently added The New Road: I-26 and the Footprints of Progress in Appalachia (2009) to my collection, but after flipping through it cover to cover, I'm sold.

When we talked on the porch of the Center for Documentary Studies in late September, Amberg was in town working on Madison County Stories, an exhibition of his new work (as Visiting Artist at Duke University) along with photographs and digital stories by Duke students and middle school youth in the Spring Creek Literacy Project in Madison County, North Carolina.

I was excited to hear that Amberg has been working on a third book project of Madison County photographs in a series he's calling ShatterZone. Here's an excerpt from the project introduction:

...If one thinks of a “shatter zone” in geological terms, that is, as an area of randomly fissured or cracked rock, possibly filled with mineral deposits that form a network of veins, Madison fits the definition. The mountains here are old, not the oldest on Earth, but ancient, worn and broken from age. The veins of these mountains don’t contain coal, or natural gas, but this lack of significant mineral wealth hasn’t stopped man from exploiting what is here – water, forests, and soil – all products of that fissured rock. From the massive clearcut early in the 20th century of what was once the largest and most diverse hardwood forest in North America, to the introduction and overuse of inorganic fertilizers and pesticides, to overdevelopment and the loss of wildness resulting from projects like the construction of I-26, the largest earthmoving project in North Carolina history, man has left an indelible footprint on Madison County’s topography...

...I sometimes think of my mind as a shatter zone – a place of cracks and fissures, each filled with contradictory and fractious thoughts and opinions about this place and our desire to live here. “You’ve got to be crazy to live out there,” is a not uncommon remark from non-residents and most people understand it takes a particular type of person – something new residents learn early in their stay. It’s not for everyone. It takes a total rethinking of your relationship within a community and requires new skills, new tools, and new ways of interacting within your surroundings. One can see the points of conflict – zoning, land use, politics, religion, culture, language – and the potential each provides for fracturing the community. Living here now is often a lesson in compromise; a reminder of man’s continual need for tolerance...

ShatterZone - selected images from a work in progress:

What I appreciate about this body of work is its authenticity, which I've come to expect from Amberg. For me, the mix of black and white and color images is best explained in this section from ShatterZone's introduction - "When I think of present-day Madison County I think of a place where people come to get away. I hear this expressed in people’s language when they speak of why they moved here; and in the words of locals explaining why they’ve never left." Present and past, these images are about community and relationship to community.

Context is not lost, which is often the case when we talk about and look at images of Appalachia. And Amberg doesn't shy away from the complexities of this mountain place. There's an awareness, and self-awareness, of a cultural matrix in this work that touches on being from Appalachia and being of Appalachia. There is no clear distinction, no low-hanging fruit, and therein lies the hard work of photographing Appalachia today.

When I think about how the world looks at us as Appalachians - me as a West Virginian, I'm reminded that it's imperative that we also look at ourselves and explore what that might mean. Have we ourselves bought into the romanticized notion of what Appalachia looks like? The wizened, weather-beaten mountaineer. Do we apply "AppalachiaGram" filters - the trailer, the dirty child, the snake-handler - for easier consumption and distribution because that's what we've been shown? Or do we cry foul when these types of images surface, not because they're not true, but because they don't "put us in a good light?"

As I continue to look at Appalachian photographs, I'm reminded that photography is more than just light and Appalachia is more than a stereotype. In Amberg's words, "Each of us comes to the work from our own distinct point of view that includes our own baggage. Art engages the personal and the universal. It’s the nature of what artists do. But I’ve often thought that of all the work produced from this region, no writer or documentarian gets it completely right or represents it for the totality of place."

NOTE: Rob Amberg will be presenting a new exhibition of work this Friday, 30 November 2012, from 6-9 p.m. at Duke University's Fredric Jameson Gallery. Details here.

 

Photographs: 1. Rob Amberg on the porch of the Center for Documentary Studies at Duke, Sunday, 30 September 2012. (RM) 2. Sodom Laurel Album, 2002 and The New Road, 2009. (RM)

ShatterZone photographs: 1. Kelsey, Paw Paw, Madison County, NC, 2012. 2. The cut at Buckner Gap, Upper Laurel, Madison County, NC, 2007. 3. Rodeo #2, Van Griffin, Marshall, Madison County, NC, 2012. 4. At the Madison County jail, Marshall, Madison County, NC, 2011. 5. Rodeo #1, Mike Schleicher, Marshall, Madison County, NC, 2012. 6. Wayne Uffelman, Paw Paw, Madison County, NC, 2010. 7. Boy with jawbone, Walnut, Madison County, NC, 2007. 8. Rodney Webb with mushrooms, Shelton Laurel, Madison County, NC, 2012. 9. My daughter Kate, Paw Paw, Madison County, NC, 2011. 10. Moosehead, Paw Paw, Madison County, NC, 2012. 11. Madison High Senior Prom, Mars Hill, Madison County, NC, 2009. 12. Suzie Mosher, the Flower Lady, Chapel Hill, Madison County, NC, 2012. 13. Marshall Christmas Parade, Marshall, Madison County, NC, 2011. 14. Stripper at Harley Rally, Hot Springs, Madison County, NC, 2012. 15. French Broad Crossing Development, Hopewell, Madison County, NC, 2011. 16. At the rodeo, Marshall, Madison County, NC, 2011.

All ShatterZone photographs © Rob Amberg.